Some stories feel like stepping into another life entirely, not just another time period, but another possibility. To Love a Lady does exactly that. With echoes of My Fair Lady and the glittering ambition of The Gilded Age, Gabrielle Meyer delivers a historical romance that is as tender as it is thoughtful, asking what truly makes someone worthy of love.
Title: To Love a Lady
Author: Gabrielle Meyer
Series: Dollar Princess Series
Genre: Historical Romance
Rating: 5 out of 5 ⭐
Disclaimer
Affiliate links can be found within this post. If you need additional information, please see the disclaimer.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
My Thoughts:
Set in New York City in 1883, To Love a Lady follows Keira O’Day, a young woman who has spent her life scraping by in the tenements, carrying unanswered questions about why her parents abandoned her. When a wealthy widow offers her an astonishing opportunity – adoption, refinement, and a chance at society, Keira steps into a world that was never meant to include someone like her.
What I loved most about Keira is that she never loses herself, even as she’s taught how to behave, speak, and exist among the elite. Her strength lies not in becoming someone new, but in holding fast to her kindness, honesty, and warmth in spaces that reward pretense.
Alexander Paxton-Hill is the kind of hero I always appreciate – reserved, observant, quietly wrestling with his own assumptions. Tasked with preparing Keira for society, he expects to teach her everything. Instead, she gently dismantles his beliefs about worth, love, and what truly matters. Their relationship grows slowly and naturally, built on respect, understanding, and shared vulnerability rather than dramatic declarations.
As the story moves from New York to England, the stakes rise without losing the emotional heart of the novel. The tension between who Keira has been shaped to be and who she truly is makes the final act especially compelling. This is a romance that values character growth just as much as romantic payoff – and that balance is where it truly shines.
Publisher’s Blurb:
For fans of My Fair Lady and The Gilded Age
New York City, 1883. Keira O’Day has spent her life scraping by in the tenements, haunted by the mystery of her parents’ abandonment. When wealthy widow and social climber, Maude Hill, offers her a daring proposition—to be adopted, polished, and presented as a society bride for an English lord—Keira sees an opportunity she can’t pass up.
Maude’s nephew, Alexander Paxton-Hill, is skeptical from the start. Tasked with teaching Keira the art of charm and flirtation, he soon finds himself captivated by her honesty and warmth as she challenges everything he thought he knew about love—and about himself.
After navigating the glittering, treacherous world of New York society, Keira arrives in England and catches the eye of the elusive Duke of Severton. She’s poised to win everything until a lavish ball, a long-buried secret, and one reckless act of love threaten to unravel it all. Now Keira must choose: the role she’s been prepared to play—or the woman she’s become.
Where to Buy:
To Love a Lady is the kind of historical romance that lingers, not because of spectacle, but because of its heart. It’s a story about choosing authenticity over approval and love over expectation. If you enjoy romances that feel grounded, reflective, and quietly powerful, this one is absolutely worth your time.
Related Reads:
Looking for book recs…
Adventures in Literature 
Leave a comment